Updated Sep 21, 2026· 4 min read· Product guide

Key takeaways

  • Identify refrigerator air and water filters separately, match their part numbers and keep model-specific replacement records without mixing reminders.

Two sealed blank cardboard filter packages on a counter with a closed refrigerator in the background
AI-generated editorial illustration; not a product test.

A refrigerator air filter and water filter serve different systems. An air filter used for compartment odors does not filter the water dispenser, and replacing a water cartridge does not replace an air filter. The useful maintenance record has a separate line for each component actually fitted to your refrigerator.

Start with the appliance model number and its own documentation. Some refrigerators have both components, others only one, and another accessory may be a produce preserver. A generic “replace filter” reminder is not enough information to choose a part.

Separate the two paths

Whirlpool’s air-filter instructions describe a model-dependent component for reducing common food odors inside the refrigerator. The page also explains that its location and status-reset instructions vary. That is a reason to identify the appliance, not to apply one button sequence across the brand.

The company’s water-filter overview describes filtration in the water path serving the dispenser and ice maker. Actual reduction claims depend on the filter and appliance combination. Do not transfer a claim from one cartridge’s documentation to another because their packages look similar.

For recordkeeping, call the components “compartment air” and “dispensed water” rather than simply Filter A and Filter B. If a separate produce-preserver accessory is present, give it a third row. Clear names help the person ordering parts and the person installing them refer to the same item.

Build a two-part identification sheet

Record Compartment air filter Water filter
Appliance identity Complete model and market Same appliance identification
Part identity Approved part number Approved cartridge number
Location Manual diagram or photo Manual diagram or photo
Reminder Exact indicator wording Exact indicator wording
Work completed Installation date and instructions used Installation and required startup steps
Next action Model-specific interval or condition Specified time, usage or other instruction

Copy the complete model number from an accessible label or purchase record. Keep letters and suffixes, which may distinguish versions. Record the source of the part number: the owner’s manual, an official compatibility tool or a written support response tied to that model.

A number printed on the old filter is useful evidence, but it is not infallible. A previous owner may have installed an incorrect part. If the old number and official recommendation disagree, resolve the discrepancy before ordering rather than choosing whichever package is cheaper.

Read the reminder before resetting anything

Photograph the display or indicator with its wording visible. Check whether it names air, water or another function. An app notification may abbreviate a label shown more fully on the appliance. Put the exact wording in your record so support can identify it.

Do not reset a reminder to make the warning disappear before identifying the component. A reset is an administrative step in the specified maintenance procedure; it does not replace or verify the filter. Keep the installation date even if the display returns to a normal status.

A reset method for one refrigerator should not be generalized to another. Use the manual for the actual model and control panel. If the procedure does not match the available buttons or screen, stop and ask the manufacturer rather than trying a sequence found for a similar-looking appliance.

Worked example: one purchase does not complete two tasks

Imagine a household sees an air-filter reminder and orders a water cartridge using an old shopping receipt. The cartridge may be a valid spare, but it does not answer the reminder. The household’s worksheet now has two distinct entries: an air-filter task still open, and a water cartridge in storage.

They find the appliance’s correct air-filter part number and record the installation separately. They do not reset the water-filter reminder, replace a recently fitted water cartridge unnecessarily or write “all filters changed” on the calendar. This is an illustrative recordkeeping scenario, not a diagnosis of a particular refrigerator.

If both components are genuinely due under the appliance instructions, list two completed tasks with two part numbers. Their dates can match without merging their identities. A later leak, odor or ordering question can then be discussed with the relevant history available.

Keep installation instructions attached to the right part

Before opening a package, compare its number with the approved record and read the relevant procedure. Follow any specified preparation, installation, flushing or checking steps for that exact water system. Do not invent a universal flushing quantity, bypass method or replacement interval.

For the air-filter compartment, do not remove unfamiliar foam or other pieces just because they resemble packaging. Identify the intended removable component in the diagram. If accessing either filter requires force, dismantling unrelated parts or reaching an unsafe position, obtain model-specific help.

After completing the prescribed procedure, record what was actually done and retain the packaging details. Keep unused parts dry and stored according to their instructions. Label spares by purpose and compatible appliance rather than by the room where they happen to be kept.

Finally, keep maintenance separate from troubleshooting. A new filter does not prove that a cooling fault, persistent odor, leak or unusual water condition has been resolved. Use the manufacturer’s relevant troubleshooting route when a problem remains. The worksheet’s job is to prevent mixed-up components and missing history, not to turn a filter change into a universal repair.

H
Homemade Heaven Editorial Team
Check manufacturer documentation and the product listing before choosing.
Affiliate disclosure. As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you. Check current retailer information before purchasing.
Refrigerator Air Filter vs Water Filter: Keep Records…Check price on Amazon